It seems that no matter if you use a hardware or a software raid controller, you should expect to lose performance when youre duplicating every write, which makes sense. If raid 5 is supported, the hardware may provide a hardware xor accelerator. Scott lowe responds to a techrepublic discussion and one members raid dilemma. You have to firstly tell your system to stop using the disk and then replace the disk. Trying to find the best raid option with what i got, so i decided to test the speed difference between onboard raid and software raid in windows. The intel raid format is fairly consistent and supported by linux.
Hardware raid and software raid are both important storage tools that we use with our systems. Normal expansion cards tend to fit best in 3u and 4u systems. Mbr install example using mdadm on and intel fakeraid. Whats the disadvantage over fakeraid on the intel ich10r. Some raid controllers are fullheight while others are low profile. So called fake raid is a name commonly applied to motherboard.
I personally avoid marvell integrated raid like the plague due to extremely poor performance worse by far than windows raid, but some of their actual hardware solutions are alright. This software raid solution has been used primarily on mobile, desktop, and workstation platforms and, to a limited extent, on server platforms. But with budget favoring the software raid, those wanting optimum performance and efficiency of raid will have to go with the hardware raid. For various reasons, i am attempting to change my system from intel rst to ahci. Difference between software raid and hardware raid in high level is presented in this video session.
Soft possibly the longest running battle in raid circles is which is faster, hardware raid or software raid. The highpoint 2700 has a marvell 9445 raid processor on board. Before raid was raid, software disk mirroring raid 1 was a huge profit generator for system vendors, who sold it as an addon to their operating systems. But the real question is whether you should use a hardware raid solution or a software raid solution. This download record provides intel raid web console 3 version 7. Dedicated hardware controller doing the processing vs. Aug 09, 2018 trying to find the best raid option with what i got, so i decided to test the speed difference between onboard raid and software raid in windows. Well, i havent used windows raid capabilities in quite a few years, but thats generally how osbased raid is. Comparing hardware raid vs software raid deals with how the storage. Mar 14, 20 get full visibility with a solution crossplatform teams including development, devops, and dbas can use.
Choosing between software raid and hardware raid depends on what you need to do and cost. Anatomy of a hardware raid controller servethehome. It is used to improve disk io performance and reliability of your server or workstation. Whilst the new code handling the raid io still runs in the kernel, devicemapper is generally. The raid implementation in winxp in my opinion is flawed to the point of making it unusable. Replacing failed disk in the software raid is a bit more complex. Software raid can have trouble with dissimilar drives. It is a way to virtualize multiple, independent hard disk drives into one or more arrays to. Software raid 1 using windows or hardware raid 1 using a raid controller. Windows raid vs intel rst vs raidz vs hardware raid. Software raid is generally slower and less reliable than a hardware solution.
A software raid is free but does carry some overhead on the server and may be less reliable under certain circumstances. For software raid i used the linux kernel software raid functionality of a system running 64bit fedora 9. A power failure could result in lost data with either one. Ive been hoping other people would post with some experience, because im in the middle of a decision and am leaning toward software but just basically fear the unknown. All products available in standard pcie addin form factor and module form factors designed and integrated into specific server systems. Low profile cards are generally used in 2u systems, but can be found in larger systems also. My experience with hardware and fakehardware raid is that as long as you stay with the same vendor, the raid metadata will be recognized ive seen this when moving drives between various hp, areca and lsi hardware raid controllers, and with intel, amd and even via hostraid i was pretty surprised when i connected a 250gb hard drive from some old amd desktop box to a hp g1 microserver, and. Id personally like to get a higherend hardware raid card to avoid this, but its not in the budget. If anything they should be advised to increase ram and be done with it. You have a lowly d525 at your disposal, which is a decent enough little cpu for serving media etc, but its not going to win you any medals performing lots of xor calcs, so offloading that to a hardware solution such as an adaptec card is prolly a good idea. Oct 30, 2015 while the intel raid controller blows the software raid out of the water on sequential reads, surprisingly the windows software raid was better in nearly every other respect. An example is intel matrix raid, implemented on many consumerlevel motherboards. However, you are likely to find that putting an additional cpu in your server to speed up software raid is less expensive than implementing hardware raid on custom hardware.
The three primary implementations of raidredundant array of independent inexpensive disks that are seen in most markets is hardware. Comparing hardware raid vs software raid setups deals with how the storage drives in a raid array connect to the motherboard in a server or pc, and the management of those drives. Intel raid software user guide for full featured and entrylevel intel raid controllers pdf click or the topic for details describes the configuration utilities for the intel raid controllers using the megaraid mr or megaraid entry imr software. This download provides intel raid web console 3 version 007. Benefits and drawbacks of hybrid, hardware assisted software raid. Aug 28, 2017 hardware raid and software raid are both important storage tools that we use with our systems. The biggest difference you are likely to see between the two is that software raid tends to be slower than hardware raid. If you really must run raid 5 on a windows machine that doesnt perform like shit you have two choices. The highpoint 2700 series are extremely low end to be sure but fake raid isnt about low or high end, it is about intentionally faking being hardware when really being software raid. I think that you are confused as to what is fake raid and what is hardware raid.
Users generally refer to fake raid when referring to products such as the intel ich10r, amd sb850, and various marvell products as another example where raid mirroring, striping, and parity calculations occur through software powered by the host systems cpu. While the intel raid controller blows the software raid out of the water on sequential reads, surprisingly the windows software raid was better in nearly every other respect. However, you are likely to find that putting an additional cpu in your server to speed up software raid is less expensive than. However, ive been seeing lots of threads all over the place and have simply wondered, what are the known advantages of using onboard raid compared to a dedicated hardware raid card. The recommended software raid implementation in linux is the open source md raid package. Windows software raid vs hardware raid ars technica. Supports 12gbs and earlier intel raid controllers using mr software stack. My experience with hardware and fake hardware raid is that as long as you stay with the same vendor, the raid metadata will be recognized ive seen this when moving drives between various hp, areca and lsi hardware raid controllers, and with intel, amd and even via hostraid i was pretty surprised when i connected a 250gb hard drive from some old amd desktop box to a hp g1 microserver, and. Does fake raid offer any advantage over software raid. Apr 22, 2003 well, i havent used windows raid capabilities in quite a few years, but thats generally how osbased raid is. Pure hardware or software raid is almost always a better choice than fakeraid. Benefits and drawbacks of hybrid, hardwareassisted software raid. Get full visibility with a solution crossplatform teams including development, devops, and dbas can use. Ich10r vs jmb36x vs windows software raid anandtech forums.
With all that said, here are my recommendations for making software raid work in debian on a system with a fakeraid controller. This is exactly why ive used intel fakeraid for raid0 on my boot drives for quite some time. Fake raid is raid that is at least partially implemented in software in the driver itself, rather than in hardware. Users generally refer to fakeraid when referring to products such as the intel ich10r, amd. In a hardware raid setup, the drives connect to a special raid controller inserted in a fast pciexpress pcie slot in a motherboard. That basically means that i use a fake raid hardware controller or a. It combines multiple inexpensive, small disk drives into an array of disks in order to provide redundancy, lower latency maximizing the chanc. It is usually os agnostic, so volumes are not specific to an os file system like software raid. What is the difference between hardware, software, and fakeraid. Socalled fake raid is a name commonly applied to motherboard.
A hardware raid controller costs money but has no overhead on the server. Hotswap support is spotty not all software raid implementations support hot swapping. Where that processing occurs can be important depending on the complexity of your raid setup. I know what advantages there are for buying into and setting up a hardware based storage array using raid technology. The pcb of a hardware raid controller is an oftenoverlooked component to the equation. Solarwinds recently acquired vividcortex, a top saasdelivered solution for cloud andor onpremises environments, supporting postgresql, mongodb, amazon aurora, redis, and mysql. Its lone advantage over pure software raid is the ability to present a single device for bios booting. A redundant array of inexpensive disks raid allows high levels of storage reliability.
Beyond that, hardware raid usually has at least options for battery backed or newer capacitorflash based write caches. Here are some tips on raid levels and some feedback on the software vs. The three primary implementations of raidredundant array of independentinexpensive disks that are seen in most markets is hardware. It is fakeraid, but a class above the other fakes and much faster than any built in parity raid in windows. Fakeraid, also known as hostraid is provided without additional cost with many motherboards. As for the hardware vs software raid question, adaptec raid cards are good at what they do. Bios raid is often nicknamed fake raid as it is easily mistaken for. Intel raid on your motherboard, is something people in the linux world refer to as fake raid and what is does is that a raid bios on your motherboard handles raid commands using the cpu to issue those commands rather then a dedicated raid controller, so under heavy readwrite situations, disk io will use more cpu resources than a real. Latest trimode intel raid controllers bring pcie nvme to hardware raid. Fullfeatured products offer raid levels 0110550660, with maintenancefree cache backup and disk encryption options. Because some minimal hardware support is involved, this implementation is also called hardware assisted software raid, hybrid model raid, or even fake raid.
After i set up the intel raid striped, the boot ssd clocked in at 12. Additionally, hardware assisted software raid usually comes with a variety of drivers for the most popular operating systems, and therefore, is more os independent than pure software raid. Fake raid is nothing more than a software raid done via a proprietary binary driverblob. Hardware raid vs software raid windows 7 help forums. Jul 07, 2009 a redundant array of inexpensive disks raid allows high levels of storage reliability. A raid can be deployed using both software and hardware. But with budget favoring the software raid, those wanting optimum performance and. It has many of the faults of both hardware and software raids, but fewtonone of their benefits.
Today we dive into what the differences are and whe we choose them. Moving the disks to new hardware will normally just work. It is generally fine, however, to use windows software raid on simple storage. Intel raid software user guide for full featured and entry. What is the difference between a software and hardware raid. Imho, im a big fan of kernel developers non directly related to zfs, so i really prefere mdadm to hardware raid. Onboard raid vs windows 10 raid speed test experiment youtube. Jun, 2016 comparing hardware raid vs software raid setups deals with how the storage drives in a raid array connect to the motherboard in a server or pc, and the management of those drives. May 24, 2005 scott lowe responds to a techrepublic discussion and one members raid dilemma. Unable to change from intel rst fakeraid to ahci discus and support unable to change from intel rst fakeraid to ahci in windows 10 installation and upgrade to solve the problem.
Additionally, hardwareassisted software raid usually comes with a variety of drivers for the most popular operating systems, and therefore, is more os independent than pure software raid. I do agree though, that hardware raid is the best choice on business class windows servers or even important. Feb 28, 2018 raid redundant array of independent disks is one of the popular data storage virtualization technology. What is the difference between hardware, software, and. Youll probably need to do something to get the system to recognize the array, but. That is what the thread was about, mainly, will raid 1 benefit enough to justify the extra risk and investment for a hw controller. A brief history of raid raid has been around since 1970s 1989 berkeley paper was a taxonomy 1989 witnessed the first raid5 in software 1990s saw many hardware raid3, 5s lsi, 3ware, maxstrat, highpoint, intel 1990s also saw the introduction of raidframe mdraid came along in 2001. Intel has enhanced md raid to support rst metadata and orom and it is validated and supported by intel for server. Hardware raid controllers are expensive and proprietary. Raid stands for redundant array of inexpensive disks. Raid redundant array of independent disks is one of the popular data storage virtualization technology. The problem well at least usually is that the drivers required arent open sourced and are not usually available for linux based systems.
245 203 1451 894 819 1099 474 1259 1576 1056 1027 1176 1298 1631 246 584 1048 273 652 264 321 1521 1576 1037 211 44 535 620 987 409 567 1197 1225 1454 264 214 320 1518 560 555 1089 428 142 48 744 1376